15 Healthiest Ice Creams Ice Creams You Can Buy Right Now

If you're looking for the healthiest ice creams to satisfy your sweet tooth, you're in the right place. Below you'll find 15 of the healthiest ice creams, frozen yogurts, and more - all with less than 280 calories per serving!

Table of Contents

The 15 Healthiest Ice Creams

I don't know many people who can turn down a few scoops of ice cream. Unfortunately, ice cream is typically loaded with empty calories, carbs, and sugar.

So, my hope is that the list I put together below of the healthiest store bought ice cream options will help you make better choices the next time you find yourself in the ice cream aisle.

The good news is that there are plenty of fantastic healthy ice cream options that can satisfy your cravings and keep you feeling good at the same time. Each option below has less than 280 calories per serving, with some as little as 10 grams of sugar.

So, I won't keep you waiting any longer. Grab a spoon and let's dive right in.

1. Bubbies Mochi Ice Cream

Nutritional Info for 1 mochi (35g):

90 Calories
3g Fat
15g Carbs
10g Sugar
0g Fiber
1g Protein

If you haven't heard of mochi ice cream before, they're basically scoops of cool creamy ice cream wrapped in springy and chewy rice mochi.

Thanks to their mochi exterior, they're the perfect bite-sized snack and they only 90 calories per serving.

These ones from Bubbies come in a huge assortment of flavors, all made from quality, natural ingredients that you can feel good about.

2. GoodPop Dairy-Free Bars

Nutritional Info for 1 pop:

90 Calories
5g Fat
11g Carbs
10g Sugar
0g Fiber
0g Protein

These non-dairy bars are the most indulgent low calorie ice cream treat. They come in all the classic flavors like Cookies and Cream, Orange Creamsicle, and Crunchy Fudge-covered Vanilla, ranging from just 80-130 calories a pop.

The secret to their premium taste and texture is a base of organic oat milk and organic cane sugar, plus natural ingredients and organic pea protein.

They also offer chocolate-coated ice cream squares and fruity popsicles, just like you used to get from the ice cream truck!

3. Häagen-Dazs Mini Ice Cream Bars

Nutritional Info for 2 bars (94g):

150 Calories
11g Fat
12g Carbs
11g Sugar
0g Fiber
2g Protein

Häagen-Dazs is famous for offering delicious traditional ice cream made with high-quality ingredients. However, their normal ice cream offerings can be pretty high in calories...so these mini ice cream bars are the perfect portion-controlled treat that keep the calories in check.

They currently come in four flavors, all featuring a soft ice cream interior coated with a snappy exterior made from real chocolate.

4. Nada Moo Dairy-Free Frozen Dessert

Nutritional Info for ⅔ cup (95g):

160 Calories
9g Fat
18g Carbs
11g Sugar
6g Fiber
1g Protein

Another great non-dairy ice cream worth adding to your shopping list is Nada Moo. It is made from all organic ingredients and sweetened with low-glycemic agave syrup. It has just the right balance of sweetness and a creamy texture comparable to regular ice cream.

5. Sambazon Açaí Sorbet

Nutritional Info for ⅔ cup (137g):

170 Calories
5g Fat
34g Carbs
19g Sugar
2g Fiber
1g Protein

Thanks to naturally rich açaí puree, this frozen sorbet has the thick and creamy consistency of ice cream despite having no dairy or milk of any kind.

Bursting with antioxidants and finished with organic ingredients, this is the ultimate frozen treat to keep stocked in your freezer.

It's perfect for making homemade açaí bowls, thickening up smoothies, or simply enjoying it by the bowlful.

6. Jeni's Ice Cream Street Treats

Nutritional Info for 1 container (83g):

190 Calories
13g Fat
19g Carbs
16g Sugar
0g Fiber
4g Protein

These snack-sized cups of Jeni's ice cream are another fantastic portion-controlled option. Every bite is decadent and delicious, with only 190 calories per container.

7. So Delicious Cashew Milk Frozen Dessert

Nutritional Info for ⅔ cup (104g):

190 Calories
9g Fat
26g Carbs
19g Sugar
<1g Fiber
2g Protein

If you're looking for an alternative to soy or oat milk based ice creams, but want the same thick and silky texture, So Delicious' line of cashew milk ice creams may be your new favorite thing.

Cashew milk gives this dessert a lush and creamy mouthfeel without the iciness you sometimes get in other non-dairy ice creams.

They come in indulgent flavors like Snickerdoodle, Dark Chocolate Truffle, and Bananas Foster, as well as chocolate and salted caramel dipped ice cream bars.

Also worth noting is that all of So Delicious' line of ice creams are made without artificial additives.

8. Wildgood Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert

Nutritional Info for ⅔ cup (126g):

190 Calories
8g Fat
28g Carbs
24g Sugar
0g Fiber
1g Protein

You might have heard of EVOO in coffee, but have you ever tried it in ice cream? Well, if you haven't yet, you might want to soon.

These plant-based ice creams from Wildgood use an extra virgin olive oil base for a dose of heart-healthy fats and antioxidants.

In addition to the health benefits, this ice cream has a silky, smooth, and creamy consistency.

It is a little high in sugar though, so go for a smaller portion size if you're trying to cut back.

9. Alden's Organic Ice Cream

Nutritional Info for ⅔ cup (89g):

200 Calories
12g Fat
21g Carbs
19g Sugar
0g Fiber
3g Protein

In addition to ice cream pints, Alden's Organic has pretty much every frozen dessert you can think of, including ice cream sandwiches, ice cream bars, frozen Greek yogurt bars, and a wide range of dairy-free options.

You're sure to find more than a few new favorites, or rediscover classic flavors made even better.

Best of all, everything is made with organic dairy and all-natural ingredients for the utmost quality and taste.

10. Tillamook Ice Cream

Nutritional Info for ⅔ cup :

210 Calories
13g Fat
22g Carbs
21g Sugar
0g Fiber
4g Protein

Tillamook has been in the dairy farming business for over a century. So, you can expect nothing but delicious, high quality cream and milk in their ice cream options.

They take it a step further by making everything with natural and equally high quality ingredients, too.

11. Noosa Frozen Yogurt Gelato

Nutritional Info for 14 oz.:

220 Calories
10g Fat
28g Carbs
28g Sugar
0g Fiber
4g Protein

Velvety gelato and tangy, probiotic-rich yogurt combine in this frozen treat from Noosa. It has a perfect balance of creaminess and flavor, but with less fat than most dairy-based options. It also boasts an all-natural ingredients list.

Just keep in mind that as far as sugar content goes, this option is one of the highest on the list.

12. Van Leeuwen French Ice Cream

Nutritional Info for ½ cup (89g):

230 Calories
16g Fat
18g Carbs
17g Sugar
0g Fiber
4g Protein

Van Leeuwen's French ice cream is extra indulgent thanks to the addition of egg yolks that give this treat a rich, custardy finish. Paired with simple ingredients and quality flavor options, these ice creams are definitely the cream of the crop.

Van Leeuwen also offers pints and dipped ice cream bars, as well as a range of non-dairy ice cream options, though those are notably higher in calories and sugar than the dairy-based lineup.

13. Cosmic Bliss Dairy-Free Frozen Dessert

Nutritional Info for ⅔ cups (116g):

250 Calories
20g Fat
17g Carbs
13g Sugar
1g Fiber
1g Protein

Cosmic Bliss offers both plant-based and grass-fed dairy ice creams, with an emphasis on using all-organic natural ingredients with no refined sugar.

Their ice cream options are all sweetened with coconut syrup and coconut sugar for a slightly lower GI, giving you that delicious kick of sweetness without the sugar crash.

14. Straus Organic Super Premium Ice Cream

Nutritional Info for ⅔ cup (122g):

270 Calories
18g Fat
23g Carbs
23g Sugar
0g Fiber
5g Protein

Take your ice cream experience to the next level with this super premium organic ice cream from Straus Family Creamery.

In addition to the organic ingredients, their ice creams are made with less air and higher butterfat compared to regular ice cream. This results in an extra indulgent flavor and a texture that can only be compared to hand-churned ice cream.

You'll want to keep an eye on your portion sizes though, as some of their flavors can get up to 300 calories per serving.